The Winners & Losers of the First Presidential Debate

9 different images of the different facials expressions of President Trump and Joe Biden during a Presidential Debate.

What did you think?

In the days leading up Tuesday’s debate, estimates were this would be the most watched Presidential Debate in American history.

In 2016, 84 million Americans watched the first debate between Donald Trump and Hillary Clinton.

Most thought this first debate of 2020 would exceed 2016 numbers. It came close. According to Nielsen, 73 million Americans watched the debate between President Trump and Former Vice President Joe Biden.

I am not sure the actual event lived up to the hype. Or maybe it did. Americans reacted to the debate with varying descriptions:



“A S**t Show”



“Turn off the mics”

I was surprised, and then again, I wasn’t surprised. Sort of sums up my entire view of 2020.

This debate was entirely consistent with everything we have seen this year.

That is why I chose the following winners and losers of the debate:

Winners: The American People

Wondering why I chose the American people as winners?

Here’s why: Tuesday’s debate further underscored and exacerbated the stark choice facing Americans in this 2020 President Election.  

President Trump and Former Vice President couldn’t be more opposite: in approach, tone, policies, temperament, governing styles, etc. I could go on and on, but you get my point.

Before Tuesday’s debate occurred, over 2 million Americans hds already cast their vote.

If you support President Trump, then more than likely you think President Trump did a great job on Tuesday. I think I heard someone on Fox News say the President demonstrated he is a fighter.

I am surprised by folks who say there were surprised by the President’s debate performance.

But why?

What we saw on Tuesday was entirely consistent with President Trump’s debate performance in 2016. He’s aggressive, ignore the rules, interrupts, and has one-liners ready to go.

Likewise, if you are Joe Biden supporter, you think the Former Vice President did a great job by not taking the bait from President Trump. Some political pundits have opined Former Vice President Biden did a great job looking directly in the camera talking to the American people.

Again, Former Vice President Biden’s debate performance was entirely in line with the way he conducted himself in the Democratic debates earlier this year. With one exception, he didn’t tell any of his Democratic opponents to shut up.

What’s my point?

My point is this debate didn’t change your mind.

If anything, it reaffirmed who you are voting and why.

For the poor souls who STILL consider themselves undecided voters – whoever you are – how in the world are you still undecided?

The American people have a choice. The debate reaffirmed why that choice is so important.

Losers: The American People

Okay, now you are likely wondering how can the American people classify as both winners and losers?

Look at it this way.

The American people won in that the debate demonstrated two candidates who couldn’t be more opposite if they tried.

The American people lost, in my opinion, because there was little to no substantive conversation about issues, policies, and what each candidate has in store for the American people in the next four years?

Brett Baier on Fox News thought “if America maybe lost on the substance at the heart of the issues.”

According to The Commission on Presidential Debates, the topics for the first debate were:

  • The Trump and Biden Records
  • The Supreme Court
  • Covid-19
  • The Economy
  • Race and Violence in our Cities
  • The Integrity of the Election

Think about it – can you name one substantive policy exchange on these topics that occurred on Tuesday night?

Was there a policy position mentioned that may have changed your mind or made you question your choice?

Maybe, but I doubt it.

Whether you are a Republican or Democrat, the American people want to hear the exchange of ideas, policy agendas, and disagreements on policy.

I’d venture to say that more substantiative debate took place in 2016 than what we heard this week.

In the wake of Tuesday’s debate, The Commission on Presidential Debates said it would issue new rules for the next debate including turning off a candidate’s microphone if they fail to abide by the rules.

Good luck.

Bottomline is depending on who you are voting for likely determines where you are part of the American people who won on Tuesday or the part of the American electorate who lost on Tuesday.

You decide.

The next Presidential Debate is scheduled for October 15.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Episode 10 | Part Two : Cristina Mendonsa

In the conclusion of Cicely’s conversation with journalist and entrepreneur, Cristina Mendonsa, Cristina shares how she started her own production company and provides some tangible advice for the next generation of broadcasters. About Cristina Mendonsa: Cristina is an EMMY/Edward R. Murrow award-winning multimedia journalist, producer, spokesperson and media entrepreneur. For over two decades, she’s demonstrated

Read More »

Episode 10 | Part One : Cristina Mendonsa

Cicely welcomes Cristina Mendonsa to Pull Up Your Chair. Christina anchors 4 hours of radio news daily while also producing documentaries, winning awards, and mentoring upcoming journalists on career strategy and mid-career pivots. In part one, Cristina talks about her first job in journalism, the evolution of electronic media, and what inspired her to shift

Read More »

Episode 09 | Part Two: Tara Jaye Frank

In the conclusion of Cicely’s conversation with  Tara Jaye Frank, the author of The Waymakers: Clearing the Path to Workplace Equity with Competence and Confidence, Tara talks about the words of advice she gives companies that are beginning their journey to creating an equitable workplace. About Tara Jaye Frank: Tara is an Equity Strategist who

Read More »
Scroll to Top

Download a free chapter of the book

Sign up for the newsletter to receive your free chapter of the book.